Pizza Stone Reviews

Our website is supported by our users.

Sometimes we earn a few cents when you click on a link.

Pizza srone reviews
We decided to have a look at and do a pizza stone review after reading that many people use them for their homemade pizzas and were very happy with the results.

What is a pizza stone

A pizza stone is nothing else than trying to imitate the brick pizza ovens that are used to make the best pizzas ever. This means that it is made of clay or a clay-like material most of the time. (read more here)
Let’s get started with our reviews.

CastElegance thermarite pizza stone for oven and grill

Codierite pizza stone round 14 inch
This pizza stone is available in:

  • 14 inch round
  • 16 inch round
  • 14 x 16 rectangular

The used material Thermarite absorbs more moisture according to the specs we read. This stone is approved in the European Union and by the FDA.
The stone can be used in the oven or on the grill and it is becoming very popular to use the gas or charcoal grill for pizza lately.

One of the big advantages is that this stone can withstand temperature shocks. No worry take it out of a hot oven and rinse it off with cold water.

The used material is a mix of many materials, mainly cordierite.

We found over 230 reviews and it received an average of 4.9 stars out of 5. The highest rating we could find for any pizza stone.
After this, it is easy to say that this is our most recommended pizza stone.



Pizzacraft PC9899 20 x 13.5 pizza stone for oven and grill

Pizzacraft rectangular pizza stone thermabond
The description says 20 inches but the real size is 22.5
Although receiving a little lower rating this pizza stone from Pizzacraft is the number one seller in the largest online store.
This is a large pizza stone and like we mentioned it measures 20 x 13.5 inches this is roughly 270 square inches and will give you the opportunity to make a large whole family pizza.

With a 4.3 star rating from over 400 buyers, this is our second recommendation and our number one recommendation for a rectangular pizza stone.

This stone is actually 22.5 inches long. Check your oven if it will fit.
It is recommended to prepare your stone by heating up the oven to 500 degrees and heat the stone first by itself before using it for pizza. After making the pizza let it cool of and rinse with cold water and a brush after scraping the crumbs off with a spatula.

Some negative reviews were about the stone smoking and smelling even after several times of using it. Try it as soon as you receive it and send it back if this happens is my recommendation. A natural material including cordoriete can not always be predicted how it works.



Old Stone oven pizza stone

old stone oven pizza stone round
The old stone oven 16-inch round pizza stone is another highly rated pizza bake stone.
16 inches is the size of a family size pizza and makes this stone great for that purpose. Store-bought or homemade can be baked on this pizza stone.
This stone is engineered to keep the heat more in the middle to prevent that soggy middle of the pizza effect you sometimes see.

The used material makes it able to withstand high temperatures and it has no problem with temperature changes and will not crack. Some lower ratings said it came cracked but only a few and this must be a shipping problem.

Several people mentioned that they put a frozen pizza straight from the freezer on the pre-heated stone and it came out perfect. Like any pizza stone, some of them smell the first couple of times when they are heated up. Most of the time this will go away very fast.




Emile Henry Pizza stone

Emile Henry flame top pizza stone round
The Emile Henry is made in France and is a very popular brand that receives great customer reviews in general. They are a little higher priced but of great quality.

They are made from all-natural materials and glazed in the colors black, granite, red, and grey. The glaze makes them dishwasher safe and very easy to clean.

Although it says 14 inches its actual size is 14.5 inches and with the handles even 17 inches.

Let’s have a look at the lower rating and what they say. Some or maybe most of the few that left a lower rating mentioned that the stone is a little fragile. But on the other hand the higher rating mentioned it is very sturdy. Guess since it is all-natural materials that this is one of the things you have to test right away and in case of even a little doubt send it back.
Arrived damaged was the second one that showed up a few times. Must be a shipping issue since most of them arrived in perfect shape.

We found 91% 3,4 and 5-star ratings. This means that the few lower rating must be seen as like with any product that the perfect product does not exist.



Pampered Chef Pizza Stone

Pampered Chef is a brand that many people look for in their search for a pizza stone and we found that this can be a good choice after reading a lot of the reviews.

We found the two most popular Pampered Chef pizza stones.

Pampered Chef rectangular 12 x 15-inch pizza stone

pampered chef rectangle pizza stone
The size is approximately but is not far of. The stoneware distributes the heat very evenly and draws moisture away.
The few lower ratings mentioned it broke in two very fast after using it for the first time.
We found 91% 4 and 5-star ratings for the Pampered Chef pizza stone on average.

This stone is not for use on the grill like some other stones are suited for both oven and grill.

We found that almost 50 people gave it an average of 4.4 stars out of 5. Pretty high score compared to some other brands



Pampered Chef medium round pizza stone with handles

pampered chef medium round pizza stone with handles
Not a lot of information to be found online but what we found was pretty good.
4.5 stars average from a little over 80 people we found so far.

The size is 13 inches round but with the handles, it is 18 inches. Some people did not like the handles because they used a pizza peel and the peel was too big to fit in between the handles.

many people mentioned that they have had their Pampered Chef for a long time and use it without any problem. Easy to clean and very easy to use in most cases.



How to use a pizza stone and what is the best one to buy

A pizza stone or as some people call it a baking stone needs to be pre-heated in the oven for at least 30 minutes and even longer for thicker crust pizza.
The reason is that a wet stone will not work and neither does a cold stone. Pre-heating will take care of both these problems.
After that just slide your pizza on it and back till it is done the way you like it.

flour the stone with cornmeal and the bottom of your prepared pizza well. This will prevent sticking and easy removal from the stone.

Cleaning is easy but let the stone cool off first. Most of them can not handle the big change in temperature and will crack. Some brands offer stones that are capable of going from hot to cold without cracking. If that is what you need read our pizza stone reviews above since we looked at a few of those.

Never use dish soap on a pizza stone. This will be absorbed in the stone pores and makes it probably useless.

Most pizza stones are made of clay or stone. The classic pizza stone absorbs the moisture during the baking process of the pizza and the result is that you will end up with a crispier crust.

There are many shapes and qualities to choose from. There are round pizza stones in a variety of diameters and there are rectangular-shaped stones.
If you like to be ready in one buy we recommend the pizza set that comes with the pizza peel.

Some people prefer a different material and that is why we will also do a cast iron pizza pan review on its own page very soon.
Altogether it is merely a personal preference and depends on your use. Do you need to get ready fast? Use a thinner stone. Need easier cleaning? Use a stone one.

In my opinion, the best pizza stone is made of clay since they come closest to the original pizza ovens used in stone oven-baked pizza restaurants.

Eddie Aiken

Blending technical expertise with hands-on experience, Eddie Aiken offers meticulous product reviews and tips for the modern homeowner. A trusted voice in home and garden essentials, Eddie’s insights ensure you make informed choices for your living space. When he’s not evaluating the latest products, he’s refining his home oasis. Your ideal living space is just a recommendation away with Eddie Aiken.

Scroll to Top